They have a large (albeit, historically isolated) population, so perhaps that help to selection out clannishness? Recommended articles lists articles that we recommend and is powered by our AI driven recommendation engine. the semai of malaysia avoid marrying anyone closer than a second cousin (i dont know for how long theyve been doing that, though) and they are a very peaceful, nonviolent population but they didnt/havent invented the western world or, say, liberal democracy (afaik! There are different versions of the genes. so, you guys seem to have applied the outbreeding practices very seriously from ca. No typical hair color, face or body features and structure, nothing common. Analysts note, however, that it is extremely difficult to get full financial information about the country due to the secrecy of the government. When you said they moved around a lotyeah! This attitude worked great back in the middle ages and it might be good to keep out floods of immigrants but it leaves something to be desired in a world where so many countries have nuclear arsenals. Stossel confidently announced that cousin marriage qualms were old fashion and the prejudice against marrying your cousin was a myth. A small percentage of marriages in the US are between cousins. Alien perspectives cant hurt. The lines on the map were drawn by me. Precisely! UK, hell of a gene pool they have). Sometimes I wonder if the Japanese just mentally transferred their clan loyalties straight to the state. The volunteers were all individuals of European descent born between 1938 and 1967. ), The decline in violence across Europe during the past millennium, which was discussed by Steven Pinker in his bookThe Better Angels of Our Nature, (discussed here: violence around the world | hbd* chick). 16,651. News on all your favorite celebs, reality TV, and movies. As HBD Chick discusses, the disappearance of references to Germanic kindreds (the Germanic version of the clan, see medieval germanic kindreds and the ditmarsians | hbd* chick and more on medieval germanic kindreds | hbd* chick) also follows this pattern: (In that post ibd rates and kindreds in germanic populations HBD Chick also examines the samples used in Ralphs and Coops analysis. The Dominican Republics Catholicism is more orthodox, and thus people are more likely to observe the cousin-marriage ban. Korea and especially Japan may experience fewer of these problems because they may be further along the outbreeding process, as Ill soon discuss. Send any friend a story As a subscriber, you have 10 gift articles to give each month. The Albanian language is a Indo-European language without other close relatives [53] that persisted through periods when neighboring languages were strongly influenced by Latin or Greek, suggesting an intriguing link between linguistic and genealogical history in this case., SOURCE: https://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/journal.pbio.1001555, Pingback: Everything the European peoples have ever lived for is being buried under a tidal wave of enemy sewage. This correlates to the rates of civic involvement seen across these countries, also discussed by HBD Chick (here and here): EDIT: Also, HBD Chick has recently posted a table of ranking nations of their individualistic vs. collectivist tendencies, from Geert Hofstedes Dimensions. While Sweden and Japan may display low levels of cousin marriages, they are isolated and like Amber pointed out, this means that everyone is fairly related after a while. Yeah Canada leading the western world in inbreeding is no surprise really. Just my 2 cents , By far the highest rates of IBD within any populations is found between Albanian speakersaround 90 ancestors from 0500 ya, and around 600 ancestors from 5001,500 ya (so high that we left them out of Figure 5; see Figure S12). To request a reprint or corporate permissions for this article, please click on the relevant link below: Please note: Selecting permissions does not provide access to the full text of the article, please see our help page How do I view content? Prince Joao, who also suffered from the genetic challenges created by inbreeding, was considered incompetent for the job of regent in 1799. consanguinity in england north vs. south mating patterns in baltic populations, The Balkans: In 2012, Eritreas total debt was estimated at 118 percent of GDP. Still other countries have had persistent problems with declining economic growth over many years. la ligne, Germany: I would add, as explanation, that if you have small groups of people which move around a lot and occasionally accept new members, the new members can add a great deal of genetic variety. oddly, many of my liberal race-is-a-social-construct friends advocate mixing all races together to achieve a beige standard presumably that would be the most outbred therefore their beige ideal may harbor the same (or worse) suicidal-to-humans tendency seen in (overly) well-outbred types perhaps the beige group would defer to different mammals:) Swedes score deceptively high on individualism, but in reality there is a politically correct conformism. Wine tourism is blossoming in Slovenia and for good reason. I think a key question is whether the population is merely all closely related, or fractured into distinct clans who are even more closely related to each other than everyone in the population is related. the zadruga But that may not be so much of a problem. 67% of Saudi Arabians are inbred. @helvena: My guesses: Iceland is most inbred because the population is smaller. We did my husbands DNA. Like many royal families, the Habsburgs made strategic . (eng), Greg Cochrans and Paul Ewalds paper on pathogens, Female Same-Sex Attraction Revisited | JayMan's Blog, https://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/journal.pbio.1001555, Everything the European peoples have ever lived for is being buried under a tidal wave of enemy sewage. See: A Tale of Two Maps Those Italians Welcome Readers from Portugal! Historically, I dont think there was a lot of internal movement in Japan, due to a pretty dictatorial state, which would tend to increase inbreeding, but that same dictatorial state really cut down on violence. The investigation continues, @staffan Perhaps the conformism in Sweden is the results of everyone being more or less related rather than small groups being highly related?. Its about whether or not the total population is sub-divided into thousands of mini populations who marry their own close cousins. As said in the post, the guestimate isnt without basis in the evidence. High inbreeding in Russia and low in Holland?hahahaha At least with the former two, a key problem is that we dont know what the regional breakdown would look like, and as my map makes clear, there should be a sharp regional divergence in historic inbreeding rates across these countries. (As well, many might note that HBD Chicks analysis generally doesnt focus on sub-Saharan Africa much. 5 Howick Place | London | SW1P 1WG. Children of consanguineous parents are more likely to be undersized or premature. inbreeding in europes periphery Genes seem to assert themselves more with age. The most significant cause for the high level of indebtedness for a number of countries was the bursting of the financial bubbles that emerged in the early 2000s, leaving the taxpayer responsible for bailing out the financial institutions which had made multi-billion losses. I for sure know that the high IBD rates in Albania and Kosovo are not due to inbreeding. #countries #maps #history #europe #africa #shorts #empire #stats #usa -----Join Disc. Our survival depends on establishing exclusive homelands for only ourselves. In the entire population, 45 percent were inbred, while 78 percent were not. Its not about the total population. Perhaps Slovenia, a bit of a paradox here, can also be a case of smooth inbreeding but of a higher degree than Sweden and Japan. Haiti is more inbred than the Dominican Republic for a few reasons: Haitis population is almost entirely African in origin theyve driven out most of the Americans and Europeans; while the Dominican population is a mix of African, European, and American. People also read lists articles that other readers of this article have read. kinship in anglo-saxon society ii But not all inbreeding is the same. jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/judaica/ejud_0002_0007_0_07175.html. absolutely! Its not an educated opinion based on research, just an observation. Fractionalization is the probability that two individuals drawn randomly from the country's groups are not from the same group (ethnic, religious, or whatever the criterion is). Oh, my family (my brother did himself) came out part Japanese on our fathers side and this is just going back 500 years. 3099067 The most severe example of the consequences of the world financial crisis in 2008, the Greek economy has collapsed under the weight of billions in debt repayments to its lenders in the troika of the EU, European Central Bank and International Monetary Fund, as well as global financial institutions. both diseases can, of course, get concentrated in inbred lineages, but the inbreeding does not cause either of them. more on inbreeding in germanic tribes The high indebtedness is in part linked to significant expenditure on the countrys defence budget, which has been considerable ever since Eritrea fought a war with Ethiopia in the 1990s. A family of old people live in a small town in Raleigh County. But what do we mean when we say that one region is more or less inbred than another? exogamous marriage in medieval england Im Hispanic and began my journey as an atheistic progressive, gradually shifting rightward until arriving at reactionary Euro-nationalism. The same thing with eugenics, @luky white male What are the inbreeding rates for European Jews? Lots of Russian blood inflow during Communist era probably when gypsies arrived, only inbred community here Southern Europe is generally considered to include Portugal, Spain, Italy, and Greece, parts of France, and countries in the southern part of Eastern Europe, like Croatia and Albania. To avoid state bankruptcy, Iceland agreed to a loan from the IMF of over $2 billion, a vast sum for a country whose total economy only amounts to around $10 billion. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. Zagreb in Croatia scores 105.7, while Rome scores a bit lower (103.8), Click to access Average%20IQ%20values%20in%20various%20European%20countries.pdf. ), since all of that was also dependent upon europes medieval agricultural system and manorialism and all of the subsequent, and consequent, economic developments since then. Ireland has increased at a high rate over the last century, and the current level is higher than the rest of the U.K. Dagestani Russian is a dialect of the Russian language spoken in the Russian republic of Dagestan, as well as in other parts of the Russian Federation. parental education and awareness of inbreeding consequences have played large roles in minimizing inbreeding frequencies in areas like Europe . Also, its worth noting that historic rates of inbreeding are just one selective force among many (not the least of which being the effects of manorialism, of strong states, and of internal population replacement ala Gregory Clark/Ron Unz) which act on a population (which may act synergistically to produce the traits we see), and close analysis may not reveal a perfect association between modern clannishness and historical rates of inbreeding, perhaps due to the vagaries of other selective forces that have been acting on these populations. neither haemochromatosis nor huntingtons have anything to do with close cousin marriages, which, as jayman pointed out, is what we mean by inbreeding in this context. Dude, please dont make me go over the problem of generalizing from cities to the whole nation yet again. around 3000 BGC Thracians settled My hat is off to you, this post is now my go-to reference on the subject. Im beginning to think that youre a geek like hbd chick. Id be remiss to not mention the effect of geography, climate, and topography on this (from Wikipedia): Mountains may contribute to inbreeding by making both farming and long-range travel difficult (favoring a pastoral way of life) see the flatlanders vs. the mountain people | hbd* chick. The debt trap initially began due to the islands reliance on imports for basic daily necessities, and when prices for these rose sharply in the early 1980s, it produced a disaster. See here. If you're in a country where everyone drives on the sidewalk and nobody stops at stop signs, you can be pretty sure you are all inbred. heres what ive got on the history of inbreeding/outbreeding (i.e. Bad Driving. anglo-saxon mating patterns The Most Inbred People Of All Time | Random Thursday Watch on Contents [ show] Where is inbred most common? Im thinking a better measure of individualism/conformism would be the variation if views, attitudes, way of living etc. more on albanians, Scandinavia: (im trying not to invoke the old GIGO computer trope for inbreeding pygmies:) i.e., do you think the relationship between level of inbreeding & whatever dependent variable is the same for all groups? This is an undertaking we might pursue in the manner Razib Khan suggested, and this might be a project we will soon address. and Haiti some time ago that may offer some perspective: World news in pictures Show all 50. But it's measured and sensible, not extreme, shouty and polarising like it is in the US. Here, the pattern in the same, Northwest European countries rank highly (with Anglos ranking highest), with more inbred countries, particularly Latin American and Muslim countries ranking lowest (see national individualism-collectivism scores). Not sure but I think the European Jewish population was quite small in the thousands? In its report for 2014, the CIAs world factbook indicated that debt levels were beginning to reduce, with the latest figure being 89 percent of economic output. Its about strong between family genetic barriers, not low overall genetic diversity (which matters little from a natural selection standpoint). These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously. I was hoping to get your impressions in particular. hasidic jews, of course, marry uncle-nieces, but i dont know for how long theyve been doing that. I mean, if everyone loves gay people, thats not individualism. As per HBD Chicks hypothesis, the Islamic countries which are the most inbred of them all cluster on an opposite pole to the Northwestern European ones. Have you read Greg Cochrans and Paul Ewalds paper on pathogens? Yes, now I can see the map now, very nice. Annual visitors: 38. As well, supporting the notion that some European countries possess distinct regional variation within them in how inbred their populations are, we have these pieces: For Britain (from traditional family systems in medieval britain and ireland | hbd* chick): And Spain (from here and here, respectively): Reinforcing the pattern we see across Europe and much of the world are the results of the Worlds Values Survey: The Northwestern European countries are in a group by themselves. Overall, the general pattern appears to be considerably longer history of outbreeding in Northwestern Europe and progressively shorter one as you move outward from there. Im beginning to wonder if the reason why I dont identify with liberals or conservatives might be that I am half and half, a mix of more inbred european stock (polish/Irish) with less inbred (English, German). To briefly mention, the problems found in East Asia particularly China may be also related to their historically high rates of cousin marriage. What Kind Of Popcorn Do Movie Theaters Use? This would be fine advice, if it were appearing on a liberal channel, maybe Colbert or Maddow Those people could use a little inbreeding here and there. A major problem exacerbating the crisis is the civil war in neighboring Syria, which not only threatens to draw Lebanon into the conflict, but has also resulted in a cooling of relations between Lebanon and the Gulf states, where a considerable amount of financing came for the Lebanese economy. They are not especially intelligent (IQ 95) but have less corruption and violence than most countries, especially for that IQ-level. Since the early 1990s, the worlds third largest economy has experienced almost continuous stagnation. The Middle East, Central South Asia and the Americas have the highest levels of inbred individuals. 6-7 the italians, the greeks, the chinese Particular among these variations is the history of Northwestern Europe, which had unique in the world a long history of avoiding inbreeding. This is a map of our current best guess of the rates of historic inbreeding across Europe and parts of the Near East. Ralph and Coop looked at identity by descent (IBD), a measure of how many common ancestors individuals within a population share. When it isnt, they keep right on offending. inbreeding in 18th and 19th century sweden We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. In total, government debt is estimated at 202 percent of GDP. my scandinavian history is more than a little fuzzy can never keep track of when the kalmar and other unions were! The Dominican Republic speaks Spanish, so there is some cross-fertilization with other Spanish-speaking countries (even if most of that happens in New York). Since then, the figure is widely estimated to have risen above 120 percent, with the economy continuing to contract until last year and then only slowly returning to growth. From their father they received so many different ethnicitiesnot one of which read Dutch! HBD: An Abbreviated History of Quisqueya and the Rise of Todays Dominicans (and Haitians) :: Concourse Expressions. BTW, theres no good reason to be rude to Jay. Conquered by Byzantium Quite possibly. With a per capita GNI of $3,540, Ukraine is the poorest country in Europe as of 2020. share. ), went down a unique historical trajectory because of it, Razib Khan recently objected to HBD Chick, Transparency Internationals 2012 Corruption Perceptions Index, HBD Chicks european consanguinity bibliography, consanguinity in england north vs. south, more on consanguinity in england (and scotland), cousin marriage in 13th-15th century england, mating patterns in medieval/early modern scotland, early and late medieval irish mating practices, mating patterns, family types, and clannishness in twentieth century ireland, runs of homozygosity in the irish population, more on mating patterns from deutschland (and switzerland), feuds, tournaments, and reproductive success in medieval germany (franconia), exogamous marriage in northern medieval italy, mating patterns in medieval eastern europe, traditional family systems in medieval russia, russians, eastern europeans, runs of homozygosity (roh), and inbreeding, inbreeding in 18th and 19th century sweden, medieval germanic kindreds and the ditmarsians | hbd* chick, more on medieval germanic kindreds | hbd* chick, ibd rates and kindreds in germanic populations, historic european homicide rates and the hajnal line, traditional family systems in medieval britain and ireland, national individualism-collectivism scores, fairly unique pathologies found in the Muslim world, Those Who Can See: Arabs and Liberal Democracy: A Primer, abridged history of cousin marriage in china, see monogamy, serial monogamy, and polygamy | hbd* chick, see:good civicness vs. bad civicness | hbd* chick, the least of which being the effects of manorialism, of strong states, and of internal population replacement ala Gregory Clark/Ron Unz, the flatlanders vs. the mountain people | hbd* chick, big summary post on the hajnal line | hbd* chick, Ashkenazi Jews are not inbred Gene Expression, Ashkenazi Jews are not inbred 2 Gene Expression | DiscoverMagazine.com, national individual-collectivism scores | hbd* chick, national individualism-collectivism scores | hbd* chick, HBD: An Abbreviated History of Quisqueya and the Rise of Todays Dominicans (and Haitians) :: Concourse Expressions, Do The White Elite Dream Of Mulatto Sheep? Ethnic Russians,a roughly 50-50 genetic mix of finnic and slavonic nations are one of the least inbred nations of Europe.Holland on the other hand has one of the highest percentages. There are hundreds of thousands of Americans in these relationships. These divisions have had great significance for the past and present of these countries and the countries they sired. How likely is that! The defence minister said in comments . Secondly, theres this map of the perceived corruption across Europe (from Transparency Internationals 2012 Corruption Perceptions Index), which produces a striking pattern: And now, here are a collection of posts detailing data on mating patterns from these various countries (from HBD Chick except where otherwise noted). Indeed, HBD Chick hypothesized that the manor system contributed to the breakdown of the clans and made cousin marriage considerably more difficult. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. there was a secular law that continued the ban up to the mid-1800s (which mustve applied at some points also in denmark and/or norway? By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. Im thinking a better measure of individualism/conformism would be the variation if views, attitudes, way of living etc. Its like the key bit from the post, man! Ill be honest, Ive no idea how youre able to synthesize all these data into posts like these, given your other preoccupations (Dont know about you, but for me, writing an HBD post is like a class project do the research, write the paper, cite the sources, etc. Charles II, known as the bewitched because of his large tongue, had a huge inbreeding coefficient. Due to mountains, large distances between villages, dangerous climate and overall poverty. but what about the english? Specifically Ashkenazi.. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.Privacy Policy | Affiliate Disclosure. Second, although not made clear in the post (and perhaps in hindsight, it should be), when we say a population is inbred, we dont necessarily mean that the average fellow in this population is more related to one of his compatriots than people in another population. When did this start? Also, as HBD Chick noted, the fairly high levels of civicness found in Blacks may be titled towards exclusive, self/in-group interested forms rather than the truly exclusive, out-group oriented ones seen in NW Euros see:good civicness vs. bad civicness | hbd* chick ). In March 2014, the debt ratio was 163 percent of economic output. @JayMan: The frequency of first cousin marriages in Portugal may lie between 1 and 2 per cent. In the case of Albanians, its pretty clear: it had fertility rates above 6 children/woman up to the 70-80s (SSA levels, while at that time in Europe, it was below 2, so a very recent population growth from few families) and still today the highest in Europe (higher than Turkey, Tunisia or Iran in the case of Kosovo) with the youngest population in Europe. This is apparently centered somewhere around level 3. In other cases, debt has been a long-standing issue, rooted in a colonial past or the exorbitant interest rates on debt repayments. One of these was that it was somehow bad to marry your cousin. The offspring of two siblings are about the same in age. If everyone was ambiguously brown, the resulting behavior from the thesis wouldnt be suicidal the problem is equal treatment towards people who fail to return the favor, which wouldnt happen in the former case. and western european societal values, England: @hbdchick Except they do since theyre recessive traits. However, it visualizes what areas we think are the most and least inbred, based on these regions histories and other pieces of evidence we have. I dont mean that you will find a shicksa in every family tree. [JayMan: No personal attacks here, thanks. The last wed already figured out because an uncle had auburn hair. Keep in mind that Ashkenazi Jews are all descended from European shicksas. Get you looking the other way. 1tn), or 13. However, I am no expert. 70% of Pakistanis are inbred. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. These individuals share similar but slightly higher numbers of common ancestors with nearby populations than do individuals in other parts of Europe (see Figure S3), implying that these Albanian speakers have not been a particularly isolated population so much as a small one. Noticeably, many Arab countries display some of the highest rates of consanguineous marriages. What Countries Are The Most Inbred? For European countries, Denmark, France, Italy, and North Ireland have a mean frequency of first cousin marriages of less than 1 per cent, while England, Wales, Germany, and Holland have a frequency probably lower than 0.5 per cent. If you imagine a population with maximal out-breeding the average level of relatedness of that population at the end of the process will be different for a population of 100,000, or one million or ten million.. The mobile Interrail Pass on your phone is the most flexible way to explore Europe. I hear they have civic clubs in Tokyo whose members go around cleaning public toilets. Hes from Liao Ning in Manchuria. See a recent comment of mine over at HBD Chicks. Those Who Can See: Chalk and cheese, Russia and Eastern Europe: you might also want to check all my other posts on the history of mating patterns in various other populations (see left-hand column toward the bottom of the page on my blog). you decide whether or not ive been cherry-picking: inbreeding in sweden Some of these countries in the 3-4 range seem to lack much of the deleterious universalist sentiments found in those scoring 1-2. The earliest was the spread of manorialism: This spread follows the Hajnal line and roughly tracks areas where there were low rates of inbreeding. Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet. http://www.researchgate.net/publication/215555434_MHC-heterozygosity_and_human_facial_attractiveness Recently John Stossel the Libertarian Fox News anchor had a show in which he debunked certain popular myths. exogamous marriage in northern medieval italy clannish medieval ireland Pingback: national individual-collectivism scores | hbd* chick, Pingback: national individualism-collectivism scores | hbd* chick, this is out of my area (& out of my league), but it must matter WHO/WHOM is being inbred e.g., if we practice the same pattern of inbreeding for centuries on a sub-saharan african pygmy tribe vs. the that exact same pattern of inbreeding for centuries on say, British Isles types (ideally we could have identical twins one a pygmy & one a british isles-er, & nevermind! as seen from this map drawn by HBD Chick (see historic european homicide rates and the hajnal line). (eng). It doesnt, but such a high drop (103->95) is unlikely. I doubt the Soviets encouraged migration on the same scales as happened in the rest of Europe during the 1900s, but of course I could be wrong. Two siblings who have kids together are more likely to pass on a disease to their children. Mountains, and presumably a closely related group of people to begin with. in early Medieval times. I think you may have hit the nail on the head. ), but in nineteenth century alsace-lorraine, the cousin marriage rate for jews was only 2.3% (compared to ca. The highest level of inbreeding in the world is found in the population of Dagestan, which is second only to the highest level of first cousins in the world. i havent gotten around to the rest of scandinavia yet. A fresh take on sports: the biggest news and most entertaining lists. Ethnic Russians,a roughly 50-50 genetic mix of finnic and slavonic nations are one of the least inbred nations of Europe.Holland on the other hand has one of the highest percentages. Required fields are marked *. 6 As can be seen from figure 1, an important cluster of countries with high levels of consanguinity is observed in most communities of NA, the Middle East and West Asia, a transverse belt that runs from Pakistan and Afghanistan in the east to Morocco . but the point is different genetic material is being inbred into each system so, different inputs (even with the same catalyzing inbreeding pattern/formula) may yield different results? civicness in france by region I think of this as grainy inbreeding, meaning small groups of highly related individuals, and smooth inbreeding where everyone is moderately related. Those isolates, however, might not be . Inbred families are the most popular in America. inbreeding in 18th and 19th century sweden A beast in a cage is still a beast, to put it politically incorrect. Since then, the rate has risen still further to over 170 percent. They divide the areas of historic outbreeding from the areas that have long-term inbreeders (based on data supplied by HBD Chick, which will be reviewed shortly), which is roughly coterminous with the Hajnal line.