Because my current save is a second attempt at the Alex Ferguson challenge. Here is a look at Intake 3 from the Control Group. . I can't remember the name of it, (and I also can't find it in the Editor), but what happens if I edit the "Footballing Importance" or whatever it's called? There are things that I can answer now, (and prove), and there are things that I can answer now and I'm unable to prove and there are things that will take more research before a definitive conclusion can be reached but I think you ask some really good questions even if some of them move on a little from the Youth Intake preview/Youth Intake to actual player development, (but I think that's only natural because it's all 1 subject really). Highest PA 167. Get the best HoYD . My theory is some of them are poached away, All of the players in my first youth intake had an D rating or lower . All rights reserved. We're looking at 16 players, (16 numbers), we're looking at both CA and PA, (32 numbers), and we're looking at 10 different intakes in each experiment, (320 numbers), so by the laws of probability you would expect somewhere in the region of 32 CA's or PA's to end in a 1 digit, 32 CA's or PA's to end in a 2, 32 CA's or PA's to end in a 3 etc etc etc etc. There are absolutely players I failed to develop properly, (especially in the early seasons of the save), and even now there are players that I fail with. Whether you're looking for tips or you're experiencing the big day for the first time, we've got all the info so you can be prepared for youth intake day in FM22. It still needs some scrolling and this is the hidden section, (so we weren't missing much). Its pretty easy, actually, but well hidden. This is simply an error that SI made when these levels were introduced, but for whatever reason they have decided not to correct the order in Junior Coaching. A high PA young player with low CA is not likely to get 1st team opportunities, (because he's not good enough right now), so he would probably benefit from going out on loan. For example: Brazil has the highest Youth Rating in the game, so signing young players from brazil makes sense. A weird single intake was observed in June. FM Tips \u0026 tricks, gameplay, wonderkids, tactic replications \u0026 tests, how-to tutorials, experiments \u0026 more. He puts the ball in the net more than any of them. 77/153 68/146 69/142 72/157 78/177 83/187 70/146 73/153 67/134 76/155 His PA ranges from 142-187 which according to my basic understanding doesn't fit him into any 1 of the existing ranges. We know for sure that Game Importance plays a role in your youth intake's potential ability, but we do not know exactly what it does. We know that there are 16 players in a standard intake although this can be increased by the poaching of players from other clubs, (so if you poached 1 player from another Youth Team/Academy then you would get an intake of 17 players, but at this stage I can't remember/confirm what happens if you are the club who has a player poached. If it is about Football Manager, then it belongs here! Whether he's right or wrong doesn't matter. The levels of Youth Recruitment are: Let's continue with our previous hypothesis that Brazilian clubs can produce 2 S tier players, 3 A tier and 4 B tier. I can neither confirm nor deny that I absolutely 100% completely agree with you,but this isn't about what you "think" or what I "think", it's about what the results tell us. 15. at the end of a players name if I have decided they don't have a future at the club as a 1st Team player. I am sure that certain cities will have certain nationalities come through. We and our partners use cookies to Store and/or access information on a device. If two clubs have identical Youth Recruitment, then the club with the highest Reputation will get the better players and will get their Youth Intake day first. On the other hand, if you are a managing team in the lower leagues, the probability of having the golden generation description during a youth intake is higher than when you are managing in the Premier League or another top league in Europe. (Perceived PA). Support FM Scout. Nothing is static. http://bit.ly/buy-fm22Football Manager videos you can learn something from. (Hopefully it should make more sense as I start to progress through it). In terms of PA, The L20 Training Facilities performed even more poorly than a pessimist on a downer might have expected. FM22 Youth Intake Tips | Increase Your Chances of a Golden Generation in Football Manager 22 - YouTube FM22 Youth Intakes are one o the best parts of football manager. Is there any truth to this or is it just an old FM players tale? The next thing I want to so is run this intake 9 more times to see what sort of return we get from 10 previews. On the 1st of every month add every newgen from the previous month to your shortlist, this takes seconds. In order. I have added the following to the list in page #6. Highest CA 118. (The laws of probability would suggest that it will be pretty even so something close to 41-41). I'm not one usually to link to my own threads, but in this instance I don't know of anyone playing the same way that I am in this save. i checked this many times and sometimes by doing this you can get a golden generation even when your youth intake preview is bad. I'm showing more than my usual interest. The last true golden generation for Dynamo Kyiv was incidentally also a class of 92-93. Something that I think a lot of us fall foul of, (especially those of us who play Youth Only saves), is that we start developing a player and we invest maybe 1 or 2 years into him and then someone comes out of the intake 2 years younger than him who has better PA, so we then concentrate on the younger guy and the 1st bloke sort of falls by the wayside. 3 players at 150+ CA. Highest PA 178. That's a flippin enormous failure in my book. 18+ - game time is more important, so if you aren't playing them in first team games at least 15 minutes a game, better to send them on loan to a level where they will get game time. Though I guess that's basically life. Every nation has a hidden attribute called Youth Rating. I have seen players develop 3 gold star PA and higher, and one of these is a first-team squad player for me now in Darren Brook. Training Facilities allowed players at the club to improve, Youth Facilities allowed the Youth players, (not yet through the intake), to improve, Junior Coaching largely impacted on Newgen CA and Youth Recruitment largely impacted on Newgen PA. Yes I might get another good right back in an intake after him, but there is no guarantee so I have to plan accordingly. Highest CA 118. I have maxed them out completely and given them State of the Art Training Facilities, (and left the others all at 1). 2. 1. What you can have an impact on. Media description. Obviously competing with the likes of Porto, Benfica & Sporting is tough when you are playing Youth Only, so I have to work hard to develop more players than normal. Those letters will keep going down until the youth intake actually comes in. Click here to read our list of best youth academies in FM22 and you'll be sure to find yourself a bargain. If a couple move into the U23s as backup, and another one makes the 1st team, you're doing well. I'm managing in Portugal and playing Youth Only and now have a B Team playing in the 2nd tier in Portugal. Most of us look at CA in terms of the stars, but if you can't develop the player from his low CA starting point to his potential PA then the high PA doesn't really mean anything. Or is that what is best for the player? That makes sense. A golden generation is in comparison to previous youth intakes. 12. When you decide to upgrade, you can see the cost of upgrading by going to finances and then expenditure. CA. 14. So the info here comes from his ability to judge players, (both in terms of CA and PA). Allow me to introduce Ricardo to you, and his 9 alter-ego's. So I will admit to being particularly curious as to what the results would show here. 14. You may know them as regens, which would be an oudated term. Then it gets more complicated. @SoSolidSnake Why do low rep clubs often seem to get players from Secondary Nations in their Intakes with high PA relative to the rest of the intake? (Perceived CA. There are things you can do to improve your youth intakes in FM 21. In Portugal, (where I have been playing in FM22), the Youth Intake preview appears in December and the Youth Intake itself appears in March, but it's different in different Nations and in the early years changes by a few days each year. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. As the club we're experimenting with in Spain is actually Melilla, (who are based on the African mainland), I would expect to see more Africans and certainly more Moroccans, but whether that's incorporated into the game I don't know. Because this is only a preview rather than the intake itself, we can't place too much importance on the quality of players. I appreciate someone doing the research on this though, enjoying the work so far. Since most of these countries tend not to have a good Stature or Youth Rating within world football, you might not get absolute superstars out of them (except for some freakish occurrence), but a couple might be decent enough for you. Highest PA 178. If you want to learn more about coach quality, I suggest reading our Training Guide. Fair play, you're right that I may have remembered that from a previous version and it's all changed since then. Youth Development is a massive part of everyone's Football Manager save. Like I said though, my understanding in this area is pretty weak so.. further investigation required again. Maybe you could add something about foreign intakes . It's tempting to stay with so many good youngsters but this is #journeyman #FM21 https://t.co/imx8yjr1Xu" One, he can pass on his Personality to your new players. First intakes are sometimes Golden Gens because the player takes it over and starts making massive improvements, so the new players coming are better. We 100% know they are wrong/lying about penalty taking). That probably gives the best of both worlds if you have good training facilities to help them too. Is it 1 potential superstar of 4-5 players who will impact the 1st Team. If the econ factor changes ofc you need to improve the background of yout intake in some lets say next 10 years. I sign everyone from my youth intake every year, and I know for a fact that some of these players, after a year or maybe two, will all of a sudden have a lot higher PA than on youth intake day. Despite producing a 90 PA player, (in intake 6), it trailed the Min. Junior coaching refers to the quality and quantity of your junior coaches. I'm not sure that Geographic location will be used like this, but then again it seems pretty reasonable. One of the largest Football Manager Communities/Forums on the internet. For that you have to look at where this info comes from.. To start off with you have to check which staff member has been allocated responsibility in this area, (and change it if needed). This attribute affects the Potential Ability of every new player generated in the country. Highest CA 112. After all, a L20 Training Facility is a flippin enormous investment. With often no communication from SI Towers we can't have known that things have changed, and it's only have much playing that we decide that we think they have changed, but we don't know how they have changed. 3 players at 150+ PA. Henrique Simal. (Nickname and full name). The only strictly educational FM channel. It covers from 15 to 30 years old. Fm22 youth intake golden generation By lt py ju ih zx . A Head of Youth Development with Catenaccio as his Tactical Style will often train new players with the Libero role and one with a 5-3-2 as his preferred formation will often produce defensive midfielders and wingbacks. 19. The dates that regens are added into the game are known as Youth Intake days. But good to see an experiment on it, does the size of town/city and location (ie port) have an effect on FGN nationalties and 2nd nationalities. At the moment I'm just sticking a few through just to get it started. The accuracy of player judgement from your staff will also come into play, as they do not get to see the exact value of a players potential or current ability. In addition to that, I have decided NOT to game the personality game where you put lots of effort into mentoring players with poor personalities into better personalities. Comparing Becks to the others in his group, what I would say is that although almost everyone knows that Becks went on loan to Preston, not many people know that he didn't stay there very long, (just a few games over a month or so I think), so if you are thinking that he went and played a whole season there then that's certainly not the case at all. The truth here is that there isn't a 1 size fits all answer, quite simply because there is not only 1 thing that influences player development. In terms of player development is there an experiment that we could run that would compare development of players who stayed in the U19's players who were given a couple/few outings in the 1st Team, and the same player going out on loan at a lower level? Then we have our affiliates, (we have 7), 2 of which are in playable leagues. We have Total CA and Total PA for each player 3 and 4 from the right. 39/64 47/57 39/88 35/63 51/62 48/74 37/108 59/74 39/80 46/84 His PA ranges from 57-108 which again doesn't fit into any single range and actually has to be spread over 4 different ranges. It should be mentioned at this stage that there is a point after which some if the player info is hard-coded, (the Youth Intake preview), and first of all I'm going to see what is decided then and what is decided at a much later date. They might be kept around to flesh out the U19's or the U23's, but every time I look at them I know they're just a filler and I don't care about their development. For ages I didn't know this and I think it was possibly Cleon's Ajax thread that finally shone a light on this, (and many other things for me. Place of birth. PA. Honestly, it makes me flippin angry when people in the FM Community make a video about something that they know very little about, and then pass it off as if they are some sort of expert or have some sort of insider knowledge that the rest of us don't have access to. I "think" the only location that is taken into account is the "Region" the club is in, (in this case Western Europe). Youth Intake Challenge FM23 Article posted on Football Manager Challenges for Football Manager 2023 Login Register FM23 . Yes of course there is a balance to be had here and if you play a player too much too young, then the chances are he will pay a price at the back end of his career. 1.5K 53K views 2 months ago FM23 Wonderkids FM23 Youth Intakes are one of the best parts of football manager. What influences the Nationality & Secondary Nationality of players? Looking at the Brazilian calendar, I would expect the Youth Intake preview some time in June and the Youth Intake itself some time in September, (but that's a complete guess on my part because it's a LONG time since I managed here). Continue with Recommended Cookies. FM22 Youth Intakes are one o the best parts of football manager. Henrique Honorato. I'm sure it's all fine though, but before we ignore it completely, I wonder what the make-up was in terms of how many were CA values that ended in a 0 digit and how many were PA values that ended in a 0 digit? This is of course, added on top of your own modifiers such as Junior Coaching and Youth Facilities. Rather than maxing out the facilities immediately and showing you all the good players that can be produced, instead I have opted to reduce all the Facilities to Level 1 for the 1st experiment and see what sort of players will be produced with minimal "basic" facilities. The last thing I would say though is that the CA/PA stars lie. There may have already been experiments to test this, although I'm not sure exactly how you might do so. Let's say Brazil (the country with the highest Youth Rating) has the potential to produce 2 S tier players, 3 A tier and 4 B tier and a bunch of other lower tier players. great work jim really interesting to read. The 1st thing I'm going to up in the Editor is Training Facilities. Im upping this because I barely scratched the surface on FM22, (was too into my save), but already in FM23 I have questions that need answering. Click on the drop down menu, open the Facilities tab, and select "Improve Youth Facilities". The next thing I look for is the Summary. If you aren't playing competitive football by the time you are 23 you should be asking yourself if you are at the right club (imo). It's very strange. You might be a manager who swaps from 1 formation to another and there is a distinct lack of width in this preview, so if you were relying on a fringe wide player to come in and make an impact then you're unlikely to be happy come intake day. 3. 6 players at 150+ PA. In terms of CA, this group came out the lowest so far, (lower than the minimum facilities where they were all set at 1). Assessing and developing youth intakes in Football Manager Published on 7 September 2022 It's youth intake day, and you're hyped for a potential golden generation. I "think" it's too simplistic to say that there is a cut-off like that, but without running an experiment it's hard to quantify, and I would expect the results of any experiment in this area to be open to significant amounts of interpretation, (which is not really the idea). Step 1 - How to find FM 2021 regen youth intakes Create a shortlist and name it 'Youth Intake'. If it doesn't give us an exact picture, it should at least give us an indication. This is why your scout with a rating of 15 in both judging player ability and judging player potential recommends a player with 5 stars in current ability. Something that's important to remember at all times when talking about Youth Intake previews and Youth Intakes themselves is that everything is relative. What it does, (accurately or not is debatable), is give you an overview of the intake at this preview stage and tell you if it's any good or not. Regens enter your game's database on specific dates throughout the season. Favoured Personnel. 5 players at 150+ PA. The staff that can be selected for the entry for Bring youth players into the club and inform you of their development is. We're all guilty of assuming that how things worked in previous issues of the game are how they will work now. FM22 Journeyman on Twitter: "We've all had a golden generation, last years youth intake was one too! Best FM22 Wonderkids FM22 Players Under 25 FM22 Transfer Budgets FM22 Youth Facilities Graphic Megapacks Cut Out Facepack V2023.06 - 10 Feb 2023 . You need to be a member in order to leave a comment. I was always personally a bit skeptical about this, but if SI make the game then surely they are going to know more than some old bloke who can't even be bothered to run an experiment to prove if what he things is true, is actually true? Thanks. I know this but at the same time every single time I select a match squad I filter by either CA stars or PA stars, (occasionally both), DESPITE THE FACT THAT I KNOW THEY ARE NOT ACCURATE AND IN SOME CASES ENORMOUSLY SO. Especially the part of different favoured persons, since it might mean my "ignore actual abilities and focus on personality/media handling" for all staff members might be proven to be a good idea (or not, as it were). This was how it had been explained and this is how we understood it to work. It used to be that each player was compared against the best player (singular), at your club, but there is a certain amount of folly involved in rating a centre-half who might become quite good at centre-half against a striker who might be a worldclass striker is always going to be a rubbish centre-half. It is commonly believed that the 1st intake of each save, (for all clubs), is boosted for some reason. 6. Interested in poaching the best Heads of Youth Development the game has to offer? All attributes, (with the exception of GK rating at this stage), (and that means I have to check the outfield rating for the GK). It says those numbers are organised due to players preferred role. What happens if I reduce/increase the Youth Recruitment/Junior Coaching both before preview and after? Though to me it seems to have an air of self fulfilling prophecy about it. I would be peeved if that didn't make a difference. @Mandy42. TBF there are a lot of really good young players at the club. Then my main question around youth intakes and player development has always been the same. Ricardo Luiz Gomes Mendes is the HoYD at this club and he has been tasked with this duty. The chances are that you will already know how the (Pro), (Amb) & (Det) tests turn out, but the Morale thing is a little different so might be worth checking out. 13. We determined at the very start of the thread, that in FM22, Nationalities were static from the point of the Youth Intake Preview and would never change. Highest CA 95. Youth Intake - An In-depth Guide on How Clubs Produce Newgens Passion4FM Trending The Unbelievable 4-2-3-1 Football Manager 2023 Tactic feat. 12. The more leagues you include in your database, the more clubs and leagues that will be included by default. i did some analysis myself in my topic but nothing compared to what you are doing. Today, Jake takes a look at how you can improve youth intakes in FM2023 so you can. Thanks very much @the_hdkGlad you're enjoying it. Before I get into the Control Group though, I have some news. Training Facilities has 20 levels, but 10 different named sections, (each containing multiple levels). 10 gives us an idea at least. Home Dressing Room - General FM and Football Discussion - II, The Dark Pictures Anthology: The Devil in Me. 6. RIght? No part of this site or its If you see a player you like, you may be able to sign them for free, creating your own factory for talented wonderkids. 11. Santander Bank ATM locations in Funes, Spain with addresses, opening hours, phone numbers, and more information including directions, maps, and nearby locations. Did you know all these tips?LIKE \u0026 SUBSCRIBE Like this video to help more people find it Subscribe to get notified of our new videos - http://bit.ly/fmscout-youtube Click the bell icon and select 'All' to not miss anythingBe sure to follow Jake's own channel and Twitter - See his FM22 Newcastle save here! Jake's channel https://www.youtube.com/c/JakeCooperFM Jake's Twitter https://twitter.com/JakeCooperFM1#FootballManager #FM22 #YouthIntakePre-purchase FM22 \u0026 get your Steam key much cheaper than Steam store. While they remain completely silent about Biereth. 7. Then you open up that inbox message 5 Ways to Connect Wireless Headphones to TV. I appreciate 10 saves is a tiny number, but the truth is I just can't be bothered to do 100, (which would give great info I think). Here is a look at intake 4 from the Control Group. Giggs, Scholes, Butt and both Neville's never did. 5. Feel free to suggest others, (but no promise that I will get to them). Total CA/PA for the whole intake is definitely something I will add. What happens if I edit the HoYD info, both before the preview and after? Liam chose to join FM22 as a striker, so unsurprisingly the virtual Liam Kemp has been a regular fixture on goal graphics across the world. 15. A high PA young player with decent CA is likely to be a decent candidate for staying at the club and playing senior football. As we have seen, the golden generation tag given to a youth intake is largely tied to the quality of your first team. Well with regards to Nationalities I'm afraid that's not the case because it's changed and is no longer set at the Youth Intake Preview. Did you know that you can track the Youth Intake worldwide? We have a centre-mid who likes like a "top prospect" and a winger who looks like a "handy prospect". As a second point, but also an addendum, when we refer to top clubs, we dont necessarily mean so in terms of quality or reputation, but in terms of Youth Recruitment. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc or its affiliates, Here Are The Best Complete Forwards In FM23, Here Are The Best Deep Lying Forwards In FM23, The Best Way to Use Inverted Wing Backs in Football Manager. 8 players at 120+ PA. Some Lower Division got intake in Late December. More than them staying in my U23 team where they use training facilities and staff I have control over the quality of. I think the basic experiment to track that would be 10 different Youth Intake Days from 10 different Youth Intake Previews. 17. Depending on the strength of your current squad, the youngsters might have a range of 3 to 5 stars on their potential. It's certainly doable and is something I have thought about before. This is where the Youth players train at the club BEFORE they come through the intake. That is, any of your U23, U20, etc coaches. Football Manager 2022 is here, which means it's time to dust off your suit and tie and get ready for another rollercoaster season. -10 170-200-95 160-190-9 150-180-85140-170-8 130-160-75 120-150-7 110-140-65 100-130-6 90-120-55 80-110-5 70-100-45 60-90-4 50-80-35 40-70-3 30-60 Trademarks and brands are the property of their respective Date of birth/Age. . 3. 2. He's 33 now and I know the end is coming for him, but he still out-performs the younger strikers despite the fact that I've got 5 younger strikers ranked above him by CA stars, (and in fact 4 of them are ranked above him by actual CA numbers). Today, Jake. (I "think"* that a staff member on the favoured personnel list influences the make-up of a plyer, but I don't know how). 9. 7. You know i'm (or was) playing with Africanos Bragana with only Cape Verde intakes. 8 players at 120+ PA. But the level of potential in their youth teams is seriously astounding. 2023 Gfinity PLC. If you would like to change your settings or withdraw consent at any time, the link to do so is in our privacy policy accessible from our home page.. I recently saw a Youtube video from [Name redacted], (because this isn't about them), about Youth Intakes and I was absolutely astonished by some of the rubbish that was being spouted. What single thing has the biggest impact on the quality of a Youth Intake? broward health medical center human resources phone number. What single thing has the biggest impact on the quality of a Youth Intake? Football Manager 2022 - Youth Intake Guide, How Youth Recruitment Affects Youth Intake, Free-transferrable Players (by 2021) Shortlist. This section is also useful if you want to track Transfers, just dont change the filter and thats that. We have 16 players in the intake (down the left hand side). 4 players at 150+ PA. Will be reading this with great interest. How Youth Recruitment Affects Youth Intake. I've got a few ideas rattling around in my head that I want to look at at some point in the future, so I'm going to add them here so that I don't forget them when I come back to this. Range is 1-200. Just like in the real world, it is just not realistic to have potential superstars coming out of your youth system each year. Even though you know they are not the same, you might be surprised by quite how different they can be. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. 11. (We know that the attributes change, including the hidden attributes, so it makes sense this would be fluid too). In this case it tells me that this "has the potential to be a real golden generation for the club". The staff at the club.